Ask for assumptions you can inspect, including available nights, occupied nights and owner costs.
Prepare a property brief
Include the address, bedroom and bathroom configuration, sleeping arrangements, parking and current photographs. Describe the condition honestly and list any work needed before guests could stay. Add the dates you want to use the home and any periods when maintenance would make it unavailable. These details help a manager decide which comparisons are relevant.
Separate the inputs
Available nights
Start with dates genuinely open to guests after owner visits, preparation and planned work. Do not treat every calendar night as saleable.
Occupied nights
Ask what evidence supports the occupancy assumption and whether it varies through the year. A visible calendar does not prove every blocked night was sold.
Accommodation rate
Ask whether the estimate uses advertised rates or achieved booking income. Clarify discounts, stay length and seasonal assumptions.
Owner costs
Include management, platforms, cleaning arrangements, utilities, insurance, upkeep and replenishment as applicable. Keep financing and tax questions separate for your adviser.
Request a cautious comparison
Ask for a lower-demand case as well as the working estimate. Discuss what changes if the home launches later, needs more preparation or is reserved for your own use at popular times. Compare the same period and cost categories if considering residential letting. Avoid taking a busy weekend rate and multiplying it across the year.
Bring evidence from an operating property
If you already host, bring dated booking and expense summaries with guest personal details removed. Note cancellations, owner blocks and closures so they are not mistaken for weak demand. Mellow's homepage invites owners to discuss comparable properties and a ballpark estimate. Use that conversation to test suitability and next steps, not as a promise of investment performance.
Sources and further reading
Reviewed 30 September 2026. Confirm current terms for your own property.
Discuss your property's rental potential
Tell us about your New Plymouth property and what you would like help with. We can discuss how our short-stay management service fits your plans.
Enquire about management →Or call 021 069 9134.

